Genesis Arbitrage

Genesis Arbitrage · · 10 min read

Stablecoins explained: what backs them, how they hold $1 and why they sometimes lose the peg

In short

  • A stablecoin stays near $1 thanks to backing and arbitrage. Below a dollar it pays to redeem it, above a dollar it pays to mint new tokens.
  • Reliability depends on the backing. Fiat-backed coins rely on the issuer's reserves, crypto-backed ones on excess collateral, algorithmic ones only on trust in the mechanism.
  • When a stablecoin drifts from $1, prices in pairs quoted in it drift too. On such days part of a cross-exchange "spread" is the gap between two quote currencies, not the coin.

A stablecoin is a cryptocurrency whose price is pegged to another asset, most often the US dollar: 1 token ≈ $1. The peg is held by backing (cash, bonds or other crypto) and by arbitrage: when the price drifts from a dollar, traders profit from pushing it back. When the backing, or trust in it, is in doubt, the peg can break.

For traders, stablecoins are the "dollars inside crypto". Profit is counted in them, they move between exchanges, and almost every trading pair is quoted in them. So it pays to understand what stands behind the 1.00 on the screen, and what happens when it turns into 0.97.

Why stablecoins exist

Bitcoin and most coins move a lot in a single day. Keeping working capital in them is awkward: while you transfer funds between exchanges, the amount can change noticeably. A stablecoin solves this. It moves on a blockchain like crypto but is priced like a dollar.

That gives stablecoins three main jobs:

Three types of stablecoins: what backs the peg

Every stablecoin promises the same thing: to be worth about a dollar. They keep that promise in different ways, and that decides how reliable it is.

TypeExamplesBacked byMain risk
Fiat-backedUSDT (Tether), USDC (Circle)Issuer reserves: cash in bank accounts, short-term US Treasury bills and similar assetsProblems with the reserves or the bank holding them; tokens frozen by the issuer
Crypto-backedDAICrypto locked in smart contracts, with collateral worth more than the stablecoins issuedA sharp drop in collateral, price-oracle failures, dependence on other stablecoins used as collateral
AlgorithmicUST (TerraUSD, ceased to function as a stablecoin in 2022)A rule for swapping into the project's own token; few or no real reservesA "death spiral": once trust is lost, the mechanism itself speeds up the fall

Fiat-backed: USDT and USDC

The issuer is a company. You hand it dollars, it issues the same number of tokens and invests the money in reserves. Redemption works the other way: tokens are burned and dollars are returned. Issuers regularly publish reports on what their reserves hold.

Only large verified clients deal with the issuer directly. For example, under Tether's published terms the minimum for direct USDT issuance and redemption is $100,000, and redemptions carry a fee. Everyone else buys and sells stablecoins on exchanges.

Crypto-backed: DAI

A user locks crypto in a smart contract and mints a stablecoin against it, much like a loan against collateral. The collateral is always worth more than the amount issued: lock $150 of ether and you can mint noticeably less. If the collateral falls below the required level, the position is liquidated so the issued coins stay backed.

The upside is transparency: the collateral is visible on-chain. The downside is exposure to the market. On top of that, DAI's collateral came to include other stablecoins, USDC among them, so trouble with one stablecoin can spill over into another.

Algorithmic: UST and similar designs

There are few or no reserves here. The price rests on a swap rule: for example, 1 stablecoin can always be exchanged for $1 worth of the project's own token. While the market believes in that token, the scheme works. Once trust goes, redemptions mint ever more of the project token, its price collapses, and the backing melts away.

How the dollar peg holds

The peg is held not by promises but by profit for arbitrageurs. The same logic applies to most stablecoins that can be issued and redeemed at $1.

  1. Price below a dollar

    Say the stablecoin trades at $0.98 on exchanges. A participant with direct issuer access buys it on the market and redeems it for $1. The difference, minus fees, is their profit.

  2. Buying lifts the price

    The more of this buying there is, the fewer cheap offers remain in the order book. The price returns to $1 and the opportunity disappears.

  3. Price above a dollar

    Say the stablecoin trades at $1.02. It now pays to mint new tokens for $1 and sell them on the market for more.

  4. Selling pushes the price down

    New tokens add supply, and the price drifts back to a dollar. Arbitrage closes the gap on its own.

This works as long as redemption is actually available and nobody doubts the backing. If the issuer pauses redemptions or the market is unsure that a full dollar stands behind each token, arbitrageurs stop buying the cheap coins, and the price can drift far from $1.

Why the peg sometimes breaks

Small deviations of a few tenths of a percent are normal: large trades and uneven demand across venues create them. A serious depeg happens when the backing itself is in question.

Well-known cases: UST in 2022 and USDC in 2023

UST: the algorithmic model did not hold

TerraUSD (UST) was the algorithmic stablecoin of the Terra blockchain and kept its price through swaps with the LUNA token. In early May 2022, after large withdrawals, UST slipped below a dollar and mass redemptions began. They minted enormous amounts of LUNA, the token became almost worthless, and UST went down with it.

The reserves the project had built up to defend the peg, including bitcoin, could not stop the fall. In mid-May the Terra blockchain was halted, and UST never returned to a dollar. The episode showed that an algorithmic peg without real reserves rests on nothing but trust.

USDC: trouble at the issuer's bank

On 10 March 2023, Silicon Valley Bank in the US was shut down. Circle, the issuer of USDC, said that about $3.3 billion of its roughly $40 billion in reserves was held at that bank. The market began to doubt that every USDC was backed by a full dollar, and over the weekend the price fell to about $0.87–0.88 on some exchanges.

DAI dropped alongside USDC, because a large share of its backing was in USDC. On 12 March US regulators announced that all of the bank's depositors would have access to their money, and by 13 March USDC was back at a dollar. The case showed that even a fully reserved fiat stablecoin depends on the banks that hold its reserves.

How a stablecoin depeg affects spreads and arbitrage

A coin's price on an exchange is almost always quoted in a stablecoin. So if the stablecoin itself drifts from the dollar, the coin's price in that pair moves too, even though the coin has not become cheaper or more expensive.

A hypothetical example. Bitcoin is worth $60,000. If USDC temporarily trades at $0.95, the BTC/USDC pair asks about 63,160 USDC for a bitcoin, while BTC/USDT shows about 60,000 USDT. At a glance that looks like a spread of more than 5%, but it is the gap between two "dollars", not between two bitcoin prices.

What this means in practice:

Using stablecoins more safely

The columns of that table are explained in the Spot – Spot table guide. If cross-exchange arbitrage is new to you, start with the lesson What is arbitrage and why it works, then move on to Spread, depth, volume: how to read the table.

Questions and answers

Which is safer, USDT or USDC?

Both are fiat-backed stablecoins with issuer reserves, but they have different companies, jurisdictions and reporting practices. There is no single answer: both have briefly lost the peg. USDT dipped to about $0.95 in May 2022, and USDC to about $0.87–0.88 in March 2023. A practical approach is not to keep all funds in one stablecoin and to follow news about both issuers.

Why isn't USDT exactly $1 on an exchange?

On an exchange, the price is set by supply and demand. Small deviations of a few tenths of a percent are normal: large trades and uneven liquidity across venues create them. The warning sign is a deviation of whole percentage points that lasts for hours.

Can you profit from a depeg?

Buying a stablecoin that has dropped is a bet that it will return to a dollar. That happened with USDC in March 2023 but not with UST in 2022. Such a trade can end in profit or in a large loss.

What happens to my stablecoins on an exchange if the peg breaks?

The number of tokens stays the same, but each one is worth less than a dollar. If the stablecoin returns to $1, so does the value. If it doesn't, the loss remains, which is why it matters to know what backs the stablecoin you hold.