Genesis Arbitrage

Genesis Arbitrage · · 10 min read

The Bybit hack of February 2025: how a signature was spoofed and what it means for exchange users

In short

  • On February 21, 2025, about 401,000 ETH plus ETH-based tokens, roughly $1.4–1.5 billion, were drained from Bybit's cold multisig wallet.
  • Nobody broke the cryptography. The attackers tampered with the Safe{Wallet} interface code, and the signers approved a different transaction from the one they saw on screen.
  • Bybit kept withdrawals open and closed its ETH gap within three days. The lesson for users is that you cannot trust an interface blindly, and funds on an exchange are a debt the exchange owes you.

On February 21, 2025, the crypto exchange Bybit lost about 401,000 ETH plus roughly 113,000 more ETH-based tokens, worth about $1.4–1.5 billion in total. It is widely described as the largest theft in crypto history. The attack did not break the exchange or the blockchain. It went through a tampered interface of a third-party service, Safe{Wallet}, which Bybit staff used to sign a transfer from a cold wallet.

Below is what is known from public sources: forensic reports, statements from Safe and Bybit, and an FBI announcement. We leave out speculation and unconfirmed details.

What happened: a timeline of the Bybit hack

DateEvent
around February 19, 2025According to the firm Sygnia, malicious JavaScript was planted in the Safe{Wallet} web interface two days before the theft
February 21, 2025Bybit runs a routine transfer from its cold ETH wallet to a warm wallet. The signers approve a tampered transaction and the funds go to the attackers
February 22, 2025Bybit CEO Ben Zhou says that about 12 hours after the attack all withdrawal requests have been processed
February 24, 2025Bybit says it has closed its ETH gap and client assets are again backed 1:1
February 26, 2025The FBI publicly names North Korea as responsible

What exactly was stolen

Several assets left the same wallet at once. Public analyses give these amounts (rounded):

AssetAmountWhat it is
ETHabout 401,300Ether, the native coin of Ethereum
stETHabout 90,400Ether staked through Lido
cmETH15,000A staking token of the Mantle protocol
mETHabout 8,000A staking token of the Mantle protocol

The dollar figure depends on the price and the source. In the first hours Bybit put the loss at about $1.4 billion, while the FBI cited about $1.5 billion. The attackers quickly swapped the staking tokens for plain ETH and spread the funds across dozens of wallets.

How the multisig signature was spoofed

Bybit's cold wallet was a multisig smart contract on the Safe platform, formerly known as Gnosis Safe. A transfer from such a wallet goes through only when several authorized employees approve it. Each one signs with their own hardware wallet. This setup is considered one of the most reliable ways to hold large sums, and it was still bypassed.

  1. A Safe developer's computer

    According to Safe, the attack began with the compromise of a Safe{Wallet} developer's work computer. Investigators say this gave the attackers access to the cloud storage from which users' browsers load the service's web interface code.

  2. A tampered interface

    A script was added to the interface code that fired only for Bybit's cold wallet. For everyone else the site worked as usual, so nobody noticed the change.

  3. Signing the wrong transaction

    When Bybit staff started the routine transfer, the interface showed them a normal transaction. What went out for signing was something else: it changed the logic of the wallet itself and handed control to the attackers' contract. The signers approved it on their devices.

  4. Draining the funds

    With control of the wallet, the attackers withdrew everything in it. According to Sygnia, two minutes after the attack a clean version of the code was uploaded to Safe's cloud storage to cover the tracks.

Technically, the transaction used a delegatecall: the wallet ran someone else's code as if it were its own, and that code overwrote the address of the wallet's logic contract. On a hardware wallet screen such an operation looks like a block of data that a person can hardly decode.

Why hardware wallets did not help

A hardware wallet protects the key: it cannot be stolen from the computer. But the device cannot know what the person intended. If it shows raw data or a hash instead of a readable description, the signature is effectively given blind, based on whatever the website displayed.

This is called blind signing. Drainers on phishing sites rely on it too, as we explained in the article on wallet drainers. The only difference is scale: there one user is fooled, here several professional signers were fooled at once.

Who the attack was attributed to

On February 26, 2025, the FBI issued a public service announcement stating that North Korea was behind the Bybit theft. The FBI calls this activity TraderTraitor. Researchers and analytics firms link it to the Lazarus Group.

In the same announcement the FBI said the attackers were moving fast, converting funds to bitcoin and other assets and spreading them across thousands of addresses on many blockchains. It published a list of related addresses and asked exchanges, bridges, DeFi services and node operators to block transactions with them.

Bybit, for its part, announced a bounty of 10% of any recovered funds for those who help trace and freeze the stolen assets. A small share was frozen. For example, the mETH protocol team recovered 15,000 cmETH.

How Bybit covered the loss

The first question any client asks after a hack is whether their money is gone. Bybit chose an open approach and did not freeze withdrawals. According to Ben Zhou, in the first hours after the attack the exchange received more than 350,000 withdrawal requests.

Bybit managed to fill the hole with its own funds and loans. That was one exchange's decision in one situation, not a market rule: a smaller platform in Bybit's place might not have had that option.

What it means for exchange users

Funds on an exchange are the exchange's obligation

When coins sit on an exchange, you do not hold their keys. You hold a record in the exchange's database and its promise to hand over the coins on request. While the exchange is solvent, the difference is barely visible. If it loses reserves, everything depends on its capital and on management's decisions.

How to spread your funds

Signing rules this case teaches

If you sign transactions yourself, in a multisig, in DeFi or on a DEX, the Bybit hack has a direct lesson.

What exchange hacks mean for arbitrage

In calm times the spread between exchanges is a price gap you can try to capture. During incidents the picture gets distorted. Exchanges may close deposits and withdrawals for some coins, and the price on the affected venue may drift away from the market.

On screen this looks like a big spread, but you cannot move the coin from one exchange to another, so you cannot close the trade. Before entering, check the deposit and withdrawal status in the D/W column; the Spot – Spot guide shows how. General rules for handling risk are in the lesson Strategies and risk management.

How much of a coin sits in the exchanges' own wallets is shown in the Exchange Balances section; the Exchange Balances guide explains how to read it. If you are still choosing venues, start with the lesson How to start — exchanges, capital, first steps.

Questions and answers

Did Bybit clients lose money after the hack?

According to the exchange, no. Bybit covered the loss with its own funds, partner loans and ETH purchases, kept withdrawals open, and on February 24, 2025 announced that client assets were again backed 1:1.

Who hacked Bybit?

On February 26, 2025, the FBI stated that North Korea was behind the attack and called the activity TraderTraitor. Researchers link it to the Lazarus Group.

Was Safe itself or the Ethereum blockchain hacked?

No. No vulnerabilities were found in Safe's smart contracts, and Ethereum's cryptography was not affected. The attackers compromised a Safe{Wallet} developer's computer and tampered with the web interface Bybit staff used to sign the transaction.

How can I protect my funds on an exchange?

Keep only working capital on exchanges, spread it across several venues and check proof-of-reserves reports. Turn on account protection and a withdrawal address whitelist, and do not trust "compensation" messages sent in the exchange's name.